How Long Is Lord Of The Flies

Sign In
Join

Lord of the Flies discussion

How long were they on the island?

Comments Showing one-25 of 25 (25 new) post a comment »

It doesn't say for sure, but how long practise you think the boys were on the island?

Peradventure two months at almost. At that place was no noticeable alter in seasons, although a tropical locale could account for that. Their wearing apparel got ragged and hair grew long. It's interesting that they fabricated no attempt to rails the passage of fourth dimension. Strange that no one had even a pocket spotter.

That sounds near right, thank you for answering :)

I think information technology was very purposeful that we couldn't track time. Time represents civilization, and so when they became savage, of course they didn't runway it. By not telling us, nosotros really got to delve into the savagery and experience the change in atmosphere.

Stephan, that's an interesting opinion. I never really saw it that way.

SPOILERS
Come across, at the offset of the volume, the boys attempted to all hold on to their civilization. This is what they'd always known. This is the environment most of usa on Goodreads live in, today. When pulled from that environment, the instinct is to go on following rules. Only of course, the environs is no longer present, and all information technology takes information technology a small group to realize this earlier culture is destroyed.

Wearing clothing is one of the first things to get. Then the boys start hurting each other. Notwithstanding, the civilized outnumber the savages, so this is fine. Still, the island is non designed for civilization. It's the savages that can catch meat. And what male child wouldn't join the savages, when they come recruiting carrying a juicy meal?

All of a sudden, the brutal side has the numbers. Ralph is the obvious option to represent the civilized side. However, it's Simon that's the God figure. Afterward all, he'southward the merely one to meet the parachutist. The only i with knowledge of the exterior world. Just then the savages destroy him earlier he can share the data. Religion comes with civilization. In other words, savages can't have an organized faith- God needs culture to survive, in this sense.

Now, when Piggy and the conch are destroyed, that's when the last chip of law and society are destroyed. At present, Ralph is the simply 1 not to exist roughshod. And he is, from the looks of it, GONNA DIE. I person cannot be a civilization. A civilization is, past definition, many people.

Being civilized in a roughshod land, can get you killed.

And information technology almost does. Merely then, lo and behold, THE Transport. It'south a touch of civilization, all of a sudden brought upon the savages. It makes them uncomfortable, the same fashion Ralph made them uncomfortable. This stops the "experiment." Just equally it says in the notes in the back of my edition, "The boys accept been saved. But who will save the helm and his ship?"

You're correct there, Stephan. The island is the world. Symbolically, anyway. Simply I don't call up it ways never lose hope. Golding has said, from the same notes section, that "everything in the book is symbolic, except the ship."

We can't interpret that as part of the story. It was just what ended the story.

When the mad become the bulk, it is the sane who are mad and the mad become sane.

Well said, Hannah.

I'chiliad glad you enjoyed it, Stephan; I'm sorry for your suffering. And I agree, that message is definitely an accurate interpretation. I believe Golding also has insight on man nature and that while we shouldn't get savage, we do. It pretty much sucks. It's depressing.

You're welcome. Carry on.

Stephan wrote: "Figuratively speaking as long as we live on globe; the conservancy of a person comes through the realization of the graphic symbol of Ralph. To live in Ralph'south consciousness these days means to be an outc..."

Excellent postal service. Bravo.

Stephan wrote: "Dramapuppy wrote: "I'k glad yous enjoyed it, Stephan; I'm sorry for your suffering. And I hold, that message is definitely an accurate interpretation. I believe Golding too has insight on human na..."

Well said. Stay Ralph.

Dramapuppy wrote: "At present, when Piggy and the conch are destroyed, that's when the terminal bit of law and gild are destroyed."

Another Excellent mail service.

However there remains 1 vestige of culture upon which the savages depend for survival--the remaining lens from Piggy's glasses, unless they somehow learn to improvise a bow and strap and learn to make fire this style. I suppose they could learn to swallow raw fish, just either mode, Merridew's power is reduced. The lens could be a reminder that the door is even so open for Merridew's clan to come to their senses.

Ralph'southward fate is not a foregone conclusion. He could kill Merridew out of self defense, regain power and bring anybody to their senses. This is true leadership, the willingness to take farthermost action when necessary.

Only that wasn't Golding'south signal.

Stephan wrote: "Golding, judging from this volume solitary, was an emissary of the light. I wish I could say the same about other writers. I fear my dearest that most modern authors are siding with Jack. I will never betray Ralph. I am Ralph."

Bravo again!

I am Ralph also, except I am willing to fight savagery with savagery as a last resort.

Dramapuppy wrote: ", at the commencement of the book, the boys attempted to all agree on to their civilization. This is what they'd always known. This is the environment near of us on Goodreads live in, today."

This what happens when people live out of thoughtless habit instead of out of living out of their values. When you know your values and live from them, environment becomes irrelevant. In this sense, Golding was entirely wrong.

Either he had non been exposed to truthful leadership or he simply wanted to make a signal, to give us a alert about the continuing real and ever-nowadays danger of fascism.

message 14: past Emily (new)

how long were they on the island

message 15: by Pasta (new)

Dramapuppy wrote: "I think it was very purposeful that we couldn't rail time. Time represents civilization, so when they became roughshod, of course they didn't track information technology. Past not telling us, we actually got to delve into ..."
I think that's actually a good point, it is a very gentle hint the author is throwing out there!

I wonder what would take happened to a agglomeration of girls under the same circumstances? Boys are always playing at killing each other. Real murder is a natural progression from this.

Kidrem wrote: "I wonder what would have happened to a agglomeration of girls under the aforementioned circumstances? Boys are e'er playing at killing each other. Real murder is a natural progression from this."

So if yous are interested in this, I recommend reading "Damselfly" by Chandra Prasad. It is basically the aforementioned volume but in the 21st century. At that place are girls and boys on the island. Very adept read :)

There are a few contextual clues to how long the boys were on the island. The flavour doesn't change and the boys pilus only grows down around their eyes, this propose they were there no more than a few months. Following the timeline of events simply a week transpires from Jack killing the get-go pig to the boy'south rescue. Things escalated to ultra violence and chaos alarming fast after the kickoff domino toppled.

message 19: past Daffy (concluding edited May 24, 2020 07:38AM) (new)

I would argue they were there for at least a yr or two, the fact that the boys' hair grows from half an inch to "a mop" suggests that the group was marooned for quite some time. The kids as well give up on beingness rescued and even forget their address and parents' names in some cases. I doubtfulness that the period was as curt as some of you suspect. The seasons changing aren't relevant and could exist accounted for by a tropical location; similar it's not gonna snow. Ironic that the boys were saved by the military, an institution based entirely on killing.

message 20: by [deleted user] (new)

Ane of the problems with the book, I felt, was that it seemed that they weren't on the island for long plenty before their behaviour changed radically.

Hence the alternative title: "Well, that escalated apace..."

Alright, information technology has been a couple years since I really read the volume so I hope I even so recollect it correctly equally I make this point.

In a fashion, time is really the center of this story. It is a master problem for the characters even if it is presented to them (in the story) and us in a sort of underlying or hidden, if you will, way. In the novel itself, there is no true definitive timeline, no real style to tell for sure how long it has been and that feels very intentional. Obviously, fourth dimension is a problem for the boys considering they aren't sure how long they volition be stuck in that location, and not sure how long they can survive. But the use of fourth dimension in this book has greater symbolic and thematic value likewise.

While the passing of time is real, the measurement of information technology is completely fabricated upwardly. I hateful, 24 hours in a solar day, 60 minutes in an hour? Come on, those numbers are completely arbitrary. And even using the ascent of the sun as worthy unit of measurement becomes capricious when you extend the problem to thousands of other planets and solar systems (deplorable to get off on THAT tangent and be THAT person).

And if you lot start thinking nearly it a little harder, its not really a leap to seeing that all culture is really only completely made upward. Accustomed, and deemed legitimate by history, just invented all the same. Actually, the things that come to be a office of civilisation are simply separated by random ideas and activity because they stood the test of time. People believed in them, so they endured.

Without being surrounded by culture, which is really just history, which is really simply fourth dimension, in that location is no such affair as civilization. And without civilization, at that place are no events or measurements that tin can legitimately measure time. It is a paradox that can only be solved by an arbitrary system and a loud enough voice to convince the masses. Time is an arbitrary system and a loud voice.

Which, incidentally, is exactly what the boys take when they arrive on the island, with the use of the conch being the arbitrary organisation and Jack being the loud voice. The boys have been removed from regular civilisation and anything that would meaningfully marking the passage of time. So they starting time from scratch. While the boys seemed, to us, to revert to savagery, they didn't practice anything and then differently from how culture are just ever fabricated. Unfortunately, the loud phonation in this item scenario was psychopathic child that incited some truly terrible and horrific practices. Ultimately, these practices would virtually likely not stand the examination of time and not become a truthful civilization, but the boys have not the use or amount of time that would eventually decide that.
I retrieve Golding purposely makes the time hard to follow to highlight and parallel this thought that culture is not a natural reality, and that people aren't naturally programmed to revert to what we consider, as a order, to be "practiced" or "normal" or "acceptable," and that we alive in a earth that has been completely constructed by random chances.

But if that isn't the respond y'all were looking for I would say they were there for virtually two months.

message 22: by Mary (new)

i'thousand so belatedly to this oh my lord

the fact that time was non mentioned, nor kept track of is very important to notation. if they were to go on rail of fourth dimension and we were to sympathize how long they've been on the island, we'd understand that the isle and boys still have a sense of organization. this is the consummate opposite of what the author was going for. if yous're a savage, yous aren't like "oh let me just kill yous and sacrifice this pig and blah apathetic blah," and so like "oh don't let me forget to put some other tally on our little agenda!" only, using the details given, we see that the conditions has not changed too much, which could accept to exercise with the setting, but information technology also could mean that we take no changed seasons. non merely this, but the boys hair has but grown down past their eyes, meaning it couldn't have been ridiculously long. not merely this, merely ralph imagines and dreams for a normal life to return, and how he wishes he had a toothbrush. if his oral hygiene got too bad or if he went several months without taking care of his teeth, wouldn't they be falling out similar leaves in the fall? if i had to guess, i'd say perhaps 2-3 months.

Dramapuppy wrote: "Stephan, that's an interesting opinion. I never really saw it that way.
SPOILERS
See, at the beginning of the volume, the boys attempted to all hold on to their civilization. This is what they'd al..."

'The mad go sane'. Trump's America?

I'd wager about half a year, 6 months is what it commonly takes for men's hair to become long and be able to use pony tails

Interesting points higher up in relation to time. I agree (having taught the book nearly ten times over the years to various Year Ten English classes) that the vagueness if time passing is a deliberate construct to usher the reader into the boys' mindset to a degree. Consider the given facts: Day and night happen as always, but no i keeps an accurate record and time's passing is a blur. It is tropical, so the weather remains warm. Rut and humidity would make Piggy's asthma harder to comport. The ten twelvemonth quondam mind is not fully formed, so in the absence of adult law and order, civilisation'south timetables collapse hands. The conch doesn't work, considering there is no adult potency behind information technology and information technology is blown randomly, non at, say 5pm, to get the boys to come in for supper. Hair grows out long plenty for a pony-tail. We tin can assume hair was relatively short (under 5cm long in most cases) at the start. Hair grows longer at differing rates in unlike individuals. I would say two months is nether-estimating. Given the weather remains tropical, the timespan sits inside a six calendar month tropical summer bike. As a teacher, I know how quickly law and club breaks down. I am going with four months.

back to superlative

Add a reference:

Search for a book to add a reference

add: link cover

Flag Abuse

Flagging a post will send information technology to the Goodreads Client Care team for review. We have abuse seriously in our discussion boards. Only flag comments that clearly need our attention. Every bit a full general rule we do not censor any content on the site. The only content we volition consider removing is spam, slanderous attacks on other members, or extremely offensive content (eg. pornography, pro-Nazi, kid abuse, etc). Nosotros will not remove any content for bad linguistic communication alone, or beingness critical of a detail book.

Welcome back. Just a moment while we sign you in to your Goodreads account.